
Author: John Mattiacci | Owner Mattiacci Law
Published April 11, 2025

Table of Contents
ToggleTrauma to the arm leads to significant consequences for accident victims, causing serious pain and limitations. Considering the ramifications, it’s understandable that you’ll wonder: How much is the average settlement for a broken arm injury in PA?
The average settlement for a broken arm injury in Pennsylvania ranges from $20,000 to $75,000. Settlement amounts vary based on medical costs, lost wages, and long-term impact. More severe fractures or cases involving permanent disability can exceed $100,000 depending on liability and insurance coverage.
As a Pennsylvania personal injury lawyer with decades of experience in negotiations and litigating in court, I’ve advocated for countless victims whose lives are turned upside down by accidents. In this blog, I’ll summarize the settlement value of broken arm injuries, the factors that affect your case, and complications in the legal process.
How Much Is an Arm Injury Settlement Worth?
When seeking compensation for a broken arm injury in Pennsylvania, it’s important to know about the two main categories of damages:
- Economic damages include tangible costs such as medical bills, rehabilitation, and lost wages.
- Noneconomic damages cover intangible losses like chronic pain, suffering, and emotional distress.
A broken arm can affect both physical and emotional well-being, so the total settlement amount often combines both types of damages, with the final figure depending on the severity of the injury and its impact on your life.

What are Medical Expenses Damages for a Broken Arm in PA?
Medical expenses are typically one of the largest components of a settlement for a broken arm injury in Pennsylvania. These expenses include emergency room visits, surgeries, physical therapy, and ongoing care. In many cases, the full cost of treatment—along with any future medical treatment required—can be factored into the personal injury claim.
It’s important to keep detailed records of all medical bills, as these will be used to calculate the amount you may recover. In addition, a medical expert may rely on your medical records to make an assessment for purposes of noneconomic damages.
Can I Recover Lost Wages After an Arm Fracture?
If you’re unable to work due to a broken arm, you may be entitled to compensation for lost wages. This includes any time off from work for medical appointments, recovery, or surgery. If your injury leads to a permanent disability or ongoing limitations, you could also recover compensation for future lost income.
To secure the full amount as compensation for lost wages, be sure to provide documentation from your employer showing the time you’ve missed and any reduction in earnings. You should also keep in mind that the Pennsylvania statute of limitations is two years. If you don’t file a personal injury lawsuit in court before the deadline, you could lose your rights.
Do Victims of Broken Arm Injuries Recover for Pain and Suffering in PA?
Yes, victims of broken arm injuries in Pennsylvania are eligible to recover for pain and suffering. This type of compensation is intended to address the physical and emotional distress caused by the injury.
The amount for pain and suffering depends on factors like the severity of the break, whether the victim experiences long-term pain, and the impact of the injury on daily life. The more significant the emotional and physical toll, the higher the potential settlement for pain and suffering.
Which Factors Influence Arm Injury Settlements?
Generally, the more severe and complex the case, the higher the potential settlement. Several factors can influence the amount of compensation for a broken arm injury in Pennsylvania. These include:
- The severity of the injury
- The length of recovery time
- The amount of medical expenses incurred
- Whether the injury caused long-term disability
Another key consideration is the Pennsylvania statute on comparative negligence. When the victim contributed to the accident, compensation could be reduced. Other factors include the degree of negligence involved in the accident and the victim’s pre-existing health conditions.

What are Sample Settlement Values for Broken Arms?
While the value of a broken arm settlement can vary widely, typical cases may settle for anywhere between $10,000 to $100,000. For example, a simple left arm fracture or soft tissue injuries could result in a settlement on the lower end of the spectrum, while more severe cases with long-term rehabilitation or permanent disability could lead to larger settlements.
In addition, you should realize that the settlement value may differ compared to the value of a case that goes through litigation and trial. The amounts may be higher, but the timeline is also extended.
What Severe Injuries to the Arm Gain the Highest Settlement?
Injuries to the arm that result in permanent disability or significant limitations often command higher settlement amounts. These injuries may include:
- Fractures to the elbow
- Trauma involving the wrist
- Nerve damage
- Injuries requiring multiple surgeries
Amputations or compound fractures, where the bone breaks through the skin, are also considered severe and often result in higher settlement values. The more debilitating the injury, the greater the impact on your life, leading to higher compensation.

Can I Recover Damages Due to a Dominant Hand Injury?
Yes, if you’ve injured your dominant hand, this can significantly affect your ability to perform daily activities and work. Because a dominant hand injury may lead to a loss of income, increased medical expenses, and reduced quality of life, it can increase the value of your settlement.
Courts and insurance companies recognize the profound impact a dominant hand injury can have, often resulting in higher compensation to account for the added hardship.
How Can I Maximize Settlement Payout for a Broken Arm Injury?
To maximize your settlement payout for a broken arm injury, it’s essential to gather thorough evidence of the injury’s impact on your life. This includes medical records, documentation of lost wages, and evidence of pain and suffering.
To support your well-being and your rights, follow all medical advice and attend appointments. Your actions demonstrate your commitment to recovery and will strengthen your case. It’s also beneficial to work with a skilled personal injury attorney who can negotiate on your behalf.
Can I Sue My Employer for a Broken Arm Injury in PA?
In Pennsylvania, suing your employer for a broken arm injury is generally not allowed if the injury happened at work. Workers’ compensation laws typically cover medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of fault. However, the sole remedy in most cases is filing a claim instead of a lawsuit.
As an exception to the rule about workers’ comp as the sole remedy, you may sue your employer if gross negligence or intentional harm caused your injury. Additionally, you can file a third-party claim if someone other than your employer contributed to the accident, such as a subcontractor or equipment manufacturer. If you’re eligible to exercise these legal options, you may seek compensation beyond workers’ compensation benefits.
What Legal Fees Should I Expect for Personal Injury Cases in PA?
Most personal injury lawyers in Philadelphia work according to a contingency fee basis, which is governed by Pennsylvania ethics rules on attorneys’ fees. Under this arrangement, you only pay legal fees if you win your case.
Typically, attorneys charge between 33% to 40% of the settlement amount. It’s important to clarify the fee structure with your attorney upfront so you know what to expect. Some attorneys may also cover other case-related expenses, such as court filing fees, so it’s important to discuss the full cost of legal services.
Consult with a Philadelphia Personal Injury Lawyer
It’s helpful to review information about the average settlement for a broken arm, but legal assistance is crucial in a real-life case. At Mattiacci Law, we have extensive experience helping clients secure the compensation they deserve for their injuries. Our skilled team is dedicated to guiding you through every step of the legal process and fighting for your best interests.
Don’t leave your future to chance—call us today at 215-914-6919 for a free, no-obligation consultation. Let us help you get the settlement you deserve.
Related Content:
- What is the Average Settlement for a Broken Bone in a Car Accident?
- What is the Personal Injury Lawsuit Process in Pennsylvania?
- How Do I File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in Pennsylvania?
- What Are the Different Types of Liability in Accident Claims?
FAQs About Broken Arm Injury Settlements in PA
How much should I settle for a broken arm?
A more complex injury, such as a compound fracture or permanent disability, will result in a higher settlement. A fair settlement will focus on the specifics of your case, including the physical, financial, and emotional consequences for your life.
What is an acceptable settlement offer?
Before accepting any settlement offer, it's crucial to consult with a lawyer to see that the offer fully compensates you for all the damages you have experienced and will continue to experience due to the injury.
What is the average payout for a broken arm?
For cases involving permanent disability or significant pain, settlements can exceed $100,000. Your settlement will depend on the specifics of your case.
What is the average personal injury settlement in PA?
Categories
- Bicycle Accidents
- Brain Injuries
- Burn Injuries
- Bus Accidents
- Car Accidents
- Construction Accidents
- COVID-19
- Dog Bites
- Drunk Driving
- Injury Insurance
- Medical Malpractice
- Motorcycle Accidents
- Pain and Suffering
- Pedestrian Accidents
- Personal Injury
- Premises Liability
- Product Liability
- Rideshare Accidents
- Settlements & Awards
- Slip and Fall
- Truck Accidents
- Worker's Compensation
- Wrongful Death
Recent Posts
- How Much is the Average Settlement for a Knee Injury in Pennsylvania?
- How Do I Fix a Police Report if it is Wrong in Pennsylvania?
- How Much is the Average Settlement for a Foot Injury in Pennsylvania?
- How Much is the Average Settlement for a Neck Injury in Pennsylvania?
- How to Describe a Car Crash in Pennsylvania