Author: John Mattiacci | Owner Mattiacci Law
Published May 25, 2025
Table of Contents
ToggleTalking about stress at work isn’t new, but getting compensated for it through workers’ comp? That’s something more folks are finally starting to explore.
Stress claims used to be pretty rare in the workers’ comp world. But not anymore.
These days, more employees are realizing that job-related stress can hit just as hard as a physical injury. And just like a back injury or a broken leg, serious stress can knock you off your feet and keep you from working.
In this post, we’ll break down the average workers’ comp stress claim settlement amounts, and the factors that could affect the final amount.
Can You File A Workers Comp Claim For Stress?
Yes, you can file a workers’ comp claim for stress in most states, but it can be more complicated than claims for physical injuries.
It’s not as easy as saying, “Work is driving me crazy.” You need more than just frustration or a bad day here and there. To file a solid claim, you’ve to show that your stress is a direct result of your job.
Not personal life. Not outside stuff. Just work.
This could mean emotional stress from a toxic workplace, anxiety from constant harassment, or trauma after witnessing a violent incident on the job.
Whatever the case, you’ll need a mental health diagnosis from a licensed professional.
Also Read: Workers’ Comp Case Closed But Still In Pain
Conditions like anxiety disorder, depression, PTSD are some examples that can be clearly linked to your work environment.
Apart from that, every state has its own rules.
Some are more open to stress claims, while others have tighter restrictions. Some states only accept claims if the stress comes from a specific event, not ongoing pressure.
Average Workers Comp Settlement For Stress Claims
The average settlement amount for workers comp stress claims is around $5000 – $50,000.
The exact amount depends on how deeply the stress has impacted your life and your ability to work. The more serious and documented it is, the higher the payout tends to be.
Here’s a general idea of what people usually walk away with:
Severity | Avg Settlement Amount | Effects |
Mild stress cases | $5,000 – $20,000 | Limited treatment, and short time off work. |
Moderate cases | $20,000 – $50,000 | Ongoing therapy and longer leave |
Severe stress or trauma | $50,000 – $100,000+ | Permanent impact. Can’t return to work. |
Factors That Affect Settlement Amounts
Workers’ comp stress settlement amounts depend on a mix of personal, medical, and legal factors that can seriously swing the outcome one way or the other.
Every case is different, but here are the main things that usually play the biggest role in what someone ends up with:
#1 Severity And Diagnosis Of Condition
This is probably the biggest factor.
The more severe your mental health condition, the more likely your settlement will be higher.
A little workplace anxiety that clears up in a few weeks is probably not going to bring in a big check. But if a psychiatrist says you’ve got PTSD after a traumatic on-the-job event, that carries a lot more weight.
A strong, formal diagnosis matters. It shows the insurance company (and possibly a judge) that your condition is real and serious.
Also Read: Reasons To Sue Workers’ Comp
#2 Length Of Medical Treatment
The longer you need care, the more your medical bills rack up. That includes therapy sessions, medication, psychiatric evaluations – you name it.
And all that gets factored into your final settlement.
So, someone who goes to counseling for a month won’t get the same amount as someone who’s been in weekly therapy for a year.
Treatment history also helps prove the seriousness of your claim. It shows that you didn’t just see a doctor once and call it a day. You’re committed to getting better. and it’s taking time.
#3 Time Off Work
Lost wages are a big part of workers’ comp. If your doctor tells you to take a break from work, those missed paychecks are factored in.
The more time you’re off, the more the claim is worth.
If you’re out for a week, that’s one thing. But if stress keeps you out of work for months? That’s a different story.
Some people are able to go back part-time or take on light duty work, and that can also affect the final amount. It really depends on how the stress affects your ability to function day-to-day.
Also Read: Can You Sue Over a Toxic Work Environment?
#4 Ability To Return To Work
This is another huge factor that affects your workers’ comp stress claim settlement amount.
Can you go back to your job at all?
Or has the stress made it impossible to return to the same environment?
If a mental health professional says you’re not able to safely return to your job (or any job) you might be looking at long-term disability benefits or a larger settlement.
On the other hand, if you’re able to bounce back and return to work without any major issues, your claim probably won’t be worth as much.
#5 Evidence And Documentation
The strength of your paper trail can make or break your case.
You need proof. That means doctor’s notes, therapy records, emails, written complaints to HR, and anything else that ties your mental health issues directly to your work.
The more evidence you have, the better your chances of a decent payout.
If your employer or their insurance company pushes back (and they usually do), documentation can make all the difference.
Tips To Strengthen Your Stress Claim
If you’re thinking about filing a stress claim, or already have, here’s how to give it the best possible shot. The stronger your case, the better your odds of a decent settlement.
These tips can really help you stand out in the sea of stress claims:
- See a licensed mental health professional and stick with treatment
- Keep a personal journal tracking your stress symptoms and work events
- Save all communication with HR or management about your situation
- Document every medical appointment and get written summaries
- File your claim as soon as you can
- Don’t try to do it all alone. Talk to a workers’ comp attorney early on
Bottom Line
Workers’ comp stress claim settlement amounts range from $5000 to $50,000.
Stress claims aren’t easy, but they’re not impossible either. With the right help, the right proof, and a solid diagnosis, you can absolutely get compensation for work-related stress.
Your payout depends on how serious your condition is, how much time you’re off work, and how strong your documentation is.
So don’t brush it off if you’re struggling. Mental health matters, and workers’ comp is there to support all kinds of injuries – including the ones you can’t see.
Categories
- Bicycle Accidents
- Brain Injuries
- Burn Injuries
- Bus Accidents
- Car Accidents
- Construction Accidents
- COVID-19
- Dog Bites
- Drunk Driving
- Injury Insurance
- Medical Malpractice
- Motorcycle Accidents
- Pain and Suffering
- Pedestrian Accidents
- Personal Injury
- Premises Liability
- Product Liability
- Rideshare Accidents
- Settlements & Awards
- Slip and Fall
- Truck Accidents
- Worker's Compensation
- Wrongful Death