
Author: John Mattiacci | Owner Mattiacci Law
Published July 11, 2025
Table of Contents
ToggleIf you’ve had two herniated discs, you’re probably wondering about the settlement you could get from a personal injury claim.
Well, you’re not alone. A lot of people in similar situations find themselves trying to figure out how much compensation they can expect.
The truth is, the settlement amount can vary quite a bit depending on a bunch of different factors.
In this post, we’ll break down the average 2 herniated disc settlement, and go over the things that will affect your final settlement. Plus, we’ll also give you some tips to maximize your compensation.
Average Settlement For Two Herniated Discs
The average settlement for 2 herniated discs usually falls between $80,000 and $150,000. That range covers most moderate cases where someone needs physical therapy, maybe a few steroid injections, and some time off work.
If you’re dealing with more than that, though, like surgery, ongoing pain, or permanent damage, your case could be worth a lot more.
In some situations, settlements go past $500,000 when there’s spinal fusion surgery, nerve damage, or proof that the injury changed someone’s ability to work or live normally.
Here’s a rough breakdown:
| Case | Treatment | Avg Settlement |
| Mild | Therapy | $15,000 – $35,000 |
| Moderate | Injections + care | $35,000 – $150,000 |
| Severe | Surgery + chronic effects | $150,000 – $500,000+, possibly $1M+ |
Factors That Affect Your Settlement Amount
A lot goes into calculating a 2 herniated disc settlement. The insurance companies, your lawyer, and the courts (if it comes to that) will look at several things when determining how much you might get.

Here’s a breakdown of the most important factors that can impact the amount:
#1 Type And Length Of Treatment
How you treat your herniated discs is the biggest factor in your settlement.
If you’ve been through multiple treatments like physical therapy, surgery, or ongoing chiropractic care, the insurance company will consider that.
Basically, the more involved the treatment, the more compensation you might get.
Plus, the length of your treatment matters. If you need long-term care or have to undergo multiple procedures over the course of months or years, that’s going to factor into the settlement.
This is especially true if the injury is something that’ll need attention for years down the road.
#2 Severity And Long-Term Impact
Next, they’ll look at how serious the injury is and what kind of lasting effects it might have on you.
If you’re in constant pain, or struggle to do basic activities, the settlement amount will reflect that.
But if the injury wasn’t too severe and you’re able to get back to your normal routine without too much trouble, your settlement may be on the lower end.
Here’s the thing: herniated discs can be complicated. Sometimes, they seem like they’re healed after treatment, but they can come back or cause problems down the line.
If your injury is likely to affect you for years to come, that’s going to be a big factor in the settlement.
#3 Medical Expenses And Lost Wages
If you’ve racked up a lot of medical bills due to the injury, that’ll be considered when calculating your settlement.
The same goes for any lost wages. If you had to take time off work because of the herniated discs, or if you’re unable to work at all due to your injury, your lost income will be factored in.
The more expenses you can prove, the higher your settlement will likely be.
Insurance companies don’t like paying out for things unless there’s solid evidence, so keeping a record of all your medical bills and pay stubs showing lost wages is a must.

#4 Strength Of Evidence
The strength of the evidence you present will be crucial to your case.
Insurance companies look at the documentation you have to back up your claims. If you’ve been consistently seeing doctors, following treatment plans, and have medical records showing the extent of your injury, that’s going to strengthen your case.
On top of that, having witness statements, accident reports, or any other evidence that supports your story can make a huge difference.
The stronger your case, the more likely you are to get a higher settlement.
But without solid evidence, you might end up with less than you deserve.
#5 Insurance Policy Limits
Here’s something most people forget: insurance limits matter.
The amount of money the insurance company can pay out is often capped by the policy, and that can vary based on the type of insurance the other party has.
If the responsible party only has a minimum liability policy (which is common), your settlement could be lower.
For example, even if your case is worth $300,000, if the at-fault driver only has $100,000 in coverage, that’s probably all you’ll get – unless you sue or use underinsured motorist coverage.
Your attorney will look into all available policies, including your own. Sometimes, multiple policies can be stacked.
What You Can Do To Maximize Your Settlement
Now that we’ve covered the main factors, let’s talk about how you can boost your chances of getting the highest possible settlement:
- Keep seeing your doctor. Consistent treatment shows your injury is serious.
- Save everything including medical bills, prescriptions, therapy notes, mileage logs, missed workdays etc..
- Don’t accept early offers as insurance companies love to toss out quick settlements to close cases fast. If you’re still in pain, don’t say yes yet.
- Hire a lawyer who’ll fight for the full value, not just what the insurance company wants to offer.
Also, don’t downplay your pain. If something still hurts, say so. Be honest about how it affects your life. That includes sleep, hobbies, work, and even things like playing with your kids or driving.
Bottom Line
2 herniated disc settlements fall somewhere between $80,000 and $150,000. If surgery’s involved or the damage is long-term, that number can go up to $500K+.
The more evidence you can provide, the better your chances of getting a higher settlement.
In the end, while there’s no exact formula, keeping track of everything and working with a skilled attorney will put you in the best position to get a fair settlement.
You deserve to be compensated for the pain and struggles you’re going through, so don’t hesitate to make sure you’re getting what you’re owed.