Do Settlement Checks Come Certified Mail?

Professional photograph of personal injury attorney John Mattiacci, a young caucasian man with short brown hair, crossing his arms and smiling, wearing a steel-blue suit, white shirt, silver tie, and wedding ring. There is a brick building and green shrubbery in the background.
I hope you enjoy reading this blog post. If you want to hire a personal injury lawyer, click here.

Author: John Mattiacci | Owner Mattiacci Law
Published June 12, 2025

Do Settlement Checks Come Certified Mail

Waiting on a settlement check? You’re not alone in wondering how it’s actually going to show up. Is it coming in a plain envelope? Do you have to sign for it? Could it get lost in the mail? 

These are all fair questions when that check is tied to something big, like a car accident or injury claim.

The delivery part might seem small, but it’s kind of a big deal when you’re expecting a payout.

In this post, we’ll explain if settlement checks come certified mail, who usually receives it and what to do if you’re expecting a check.

Do Settlement Checks Come Certified Mail?

Yes, settlement checks often do come through certified mail, but not always. 

There are a few different ways they can be sent out, depending on who’s handling the payout and how much money is involved.

A lot of attorneys and insurance companies like to play it safe. They’ll send the check using certified mail, priority mail, or with a private courier like FedEx or UPS. These methods usually include tracking and may even require a signature when it arrives. 

That said, not every check comes this way. In some smaller cases or high-volume claims, they might just drop it in the regular mail.  So it kind of depends on how careful the sender wants to be.

Also Read: Can A Settlement Check Be Direct Deposited?

Why Certified or Tracked Mail Is Often Used

Settlement checks aren’t pocket change. They’re often for thousands (or more), and no one wants that kind of money to go missing in the mail. 

That’s why certified or tracked mail is so popular.

When someone sends a check via certified mail, they get a tracking number and proof that it was delivered. Even better, they can require a signature, which makes it harder for the envelope to disappear into the wrong hands. 

Same goes for services like FedEx or UPS – those come with real-time tracking updates and signatures as well.

Why Certified or Tracked Mail Is Often Used

This kind of delivery method helps protect everyone involved. The sender knows the check got to you. You know when to expect it. And if something goes wrong, there’s a clear trail to follow. 

It’s just a good way to avoid headaches.

Also Read: How Much Of A $100K Settlement Will I Get?

Class Action And Mass Tort Cases

Class actions or mass torts are those big cases with lots of people involved.

If you’re part of one of those, the process is a bit different.

These checks usually get sent out in bulk, and honestly, most of the time they’re just mailed through standard first-class mail. 

It’s way cheaper and faster for whoever is in charge of sending them out, especially when there are hundreds or thousands of people waiting for their payment.

That means you might not get tracking, and there probably won’t be a signature required. 

So, it’s a little less secure, but that’s just how it’s done most of the time.

If you’re in this kind of case and your check hasn’t shown up after a while, don’t panic. It might just be taking the scenic route. But definitely follow up if it’s been weeks and there’s still nothing in your mailbox.

Who Usually Receives the Check?

If you’ve hired an attorney, the check probably isn’t coming straight to your house. It’ll usually go to your attorney’s office first. 

That’s totally normal. The insurance company or the opposing party sends the check to your lawyer, who then handles all the behind-the-scenes stuff before giving you your portion.

Also Read: Lawyer Lied About Settlement Amount

Why the extra step? Your attorney may need to take care of a few things before you get paid. That might include paying off any medical bills or liens connected to your case, covering legal fees, and making sure everything is documented correctly. 

After that, they’ll send you your share, usually with a detailed breakdown of all the deductions.

Now, if you’re not working with a lawyer, the check might come directly to you. And in those cases, it’s more common for the sender to use certified mail or some other tracked method.

What You Should Do When Expecting A Check
Your Path To Recovery
Need Award Winning Representation for Your Personal Injury Case?
Our experts are ready to help you claim the compensation you need to move forward.

What You Should Do When Expecting A Check

So you know a check is coming – now what? Here are a few simple steps to stay ahead:

  • Ask your lawyer or claims administrator how the check will be sent
  • If there’s tracking, get the number and keep an eye on it
  • Make sure someone is around to sign for it if needed

If your lawyer is handling the payout, they’ll usually let you know once they’ve got the check and when you can expect your cut. They might mail it to you, or they might ask you to pick it up. Either way, communication is important here.

Also, don’t forget that even after the check is mailed, it might take a few days to clear depending on your bank. 

So give it some time once you’ve deposited it.

Bottom Line

Most settlement checks are sent using certified mail or a tracked service. 

It’s not a legal requirement, but it just makes sense when that much money is involved. Lawyers, insurance companies, and other senders don’t want to risk a lost check any more than you do.

That said, if you’re in a class action or a simpler case, your check could arrive by regular mail. It all depends on the situation.

So don’t stress too much. Just check in with your lawyer (or whoever’s handling the payout), ask how it’s being sent, and keep your eyes on the mailbox.

FAQs

Do Lawyers Mail Settlement Checks?

Yes, most of the time lawyers handle the settlement check once it’s received from the insurance company. After the funds are processed (usually through a trust account) they’ll mail you a check for your portion. 

Some firms also offer options like in-person pickup or direct deposit, depending on what you agree to ahead of time.

What Does A Settlement Check Look Like?

A settlement check usually looks like a regular business check. It will include:

  • The name of the paying party (usually the insurance company)
  • The amount of the settlement
  • A check number and date
  • Your name or your attorney’s name as the payee

Sometimes it’ll also say things like “Settlement Payment” or reference a claim number. It won’t look fancy, but it’s very official so handle it with care!

Quick Links