
Author: John Mattiacci | Owner Mattiacci Law
Published February 9, 2025

Table of Contents
ToggleWondering how much does an attorney charge for a car accident claim in New Jersey? The short answer is: it depends. In New Jersey, personal injury attorneys commonly operate on a contingency fee basis, with fees structured as follows: 33⅓% on the first $750,000 recovered, 30% on the next $750,000, 25% on the next $750,000, and 20% on any amount exceeding $2.25 million. Without upfront costs, you’ll only pay if your attorney is successful. This article prepares you for a detailed exploration of how these fees work, including the factors that can influence the cost and other potential expenses involved in pursuing a car accident claim.
Key Takeaways
- Personal injury attorneys in New Jersey usually work on a contingency fee arrangement, taking approximately 33⅓% to 40% from settlements and court awards, incentivizing them to secure the best outcome for their clients.
- Clients may also be responsible for additional fees and costs related to their car accident claim, such as court fees and expenses for obtaining records, which may be deducted from the final settlement or judgment.
- Hiring a skilled personal injury attorney increases the potential for a higher compensation amount, provides expertise in navigating complex legal processes, and ensures comprehensive representation in car accident cases.
Contingency Fee Structure in New Jersey Car Accident Cases
Within the scope of personal injury cases arising from car accidents, a vast majority of attorneys in New Jersey engage their clients based on a contingency fee model. Under this arrangement, an attorney’s payment is dependent upon securing either a settlement or victory for your case. In simple terms, should they fail to win your case, you are not required to pay them anything. This method aligns the lawyer’s financial interest with that of their client since earning legal fees relies entirely on achieving favorable results.
In New Jersey, contingency fees for personal injury cases are regulated by court rules. These typically stipulate the following structure: 33⅓% on the first $750,000 recovered, 30% on the next $750,000, 25% on the next $750,000, and 20% on any amount exceeding $2.25 million. This tiered system applies regardless of whether the case settles or proceeds to trial, and attorneys must clearly outline this arrangement in the client agreement. It is worth noting that while these are the maximum allowable percentages, specific agreements may include lower rates depending on the complexity of the case or negotiations between the client and the attorney.

Contingency Fee Percentage Range
In New Jersey, attorneys handling car accident cases usually operate on a contingency fee basis. While the court rules cap fees at specific percentages (33⅓% for the first $750,000, etc.), the effective percentage can vary between 20% and 33⅓% in practice. Attorneys may choose to charge lower percentages in cases that are straightforward or where substantial damages are expected. Conversely, fees may approach the maximum allowed by law in more complex cases requiring extensive litigation.
If your case requires filing a lawsuit, additional work and preparation could result in fees that are closer to the upper limit of the allowable range. These fees should always be discussed in detail before signing an agreement to ensure clarity on what percentage will apply to your case.
Comparison of Car Accident Attorney Fees and Costs in New Jersey
The following table summarizes typical fees and costs you might encounter when hiring a car accident attorney in New Jersey. These ranges provide an overview but may vary based on the specifics of your case and your attorney’s policies.
Aspect | Typical Range/Details | Explanation |
---|---|---|
Contingency Fee | 25% – 33⅓% | Lawyers take a percentage of the final settlement. |
Settlement Stage Fees | ~33⅓% | Standard rate if the case is resolved outside of court. |
Trial Stage Fees | ~40% | Higher rate due to the additional work of going to trial. |
Additional Case Expenses | Varies ($200 – $5,000+) | Costs for investigations, expert witnesses, court fees, etc. |
Retainer Fee | Rare (<$1,000) | Occasionally used but uncommon for car accident cases. |
Hourly Rate | Rare ($100 – $500/hour) | Typically used only in specific, limited-scope consultations. |
Typical Settlement Range | $5,000 – $30,000 (varies widely) | Average settlements depend on case specifics and damages. Larger settlements are common in severe cases. |
Factors Affecting Contingency Fee Percentage
Be mindful that the percentage of a contingency fee can be affected by several factors. Complex legal matters, which require more time and specialized knowledge, typically result in higher fees due to the elevated efforts involved. When there’s a greater degree of uncertainty or formidable obstacles in achieving a positive outcome legally speaking, lawyers may charge increased rates reflecting the heightened risk.
Conversely, when substantial settlements are on the table, this could create an opportunity to negotiate for reduced contingency fee percentages due to larger potential recovery amounts providing some leeway. With smaller settlements, anticipated outcomes might not allow much room for adjustment of fees. It is standard practice within legal realms to tailor contingency fees based upon each case’s distinctive characteristics and expected results.
Other Fee Arrangements and Expenses
While the contingency fee model is standard for personal injury cases in New Jersey, other fee structures may occasionally apply in specific scenarios. Flat fees, for instance, might be used for limited legal tasks, and retainer fees may be requested in rare cases requiring extensive upfront work. All attorneys are obligated to disclose the terms of their fee arrangements and explain any additional costs in their contracts, ensuring transparency for clients.
Typical additional expenses during a car accident claim include:
- Fees for obtaining medical and police records
- Costs associated with depositions or court filings
- Expert witness fees
- Administrative costs for case preparation
Law firms often advance these costs on behalf of the client, recovering them from the final settlement or judgment. It is advisable to discuss these potential expenses with your attorney before proceeding to avoid surprises.

Retainer Fees and Hourly Rates
Occasionally, attorneys specializing in car accident cases may request a retainer fee as an upfront charge to commence their legal services. These lawyers might also provide the option of charging clients according to an hourly rate for the amount of time spent on the case. The terms and any initial charges involved will be clearly specified in the attorney’s retainer agreement.
Should a case conclude favorably, it’s common practice for the initially paid retainer fee to be subtracted from the total contingency fee due, thereby counting towards what is ultimately owed by the client as part of their initial outlay toward final legal costs.
Case-Related Costs and Expenses
Clients may be liable for various expenses and costs associated with their case, such as:
- Fees directly payable to the court
- Expenditures incurred while obtaining medical records
- Costs related to acquiring police reports
- Fees attributed to expert witnesses
- Expenses owing to court reporters
Mattiacci Injury Law adopts a ‘No-Fee Policy’ whereby all charges pertinent to the client’s legal matter are advanced by the firm. The law firm only imposes fees following successful monetary recovery on behalf of the client.
Typically, clients should expect to disburse attorney’s fees and related expenses promptly as they come due. Neglecting these payments can impede case proceedings unless assumed by the law firm at an earlier stage. These financial obligations usually get subtracted from either the settlement amount or the final judgment awarded in favor of our client. This method ensures that attorneys’ remunerations are computed post deduction of settlement amounts.
The Value of Hiring a Car Accident Attorney in New Jersey
Securing experienced legal representation not only improves your chances of obtaining fair compensation but also ensures compliance with New Jersey’s strict legal requirements, such as filing within the two-year statute of limitations. Experienced attorneys can also guide clients through the state’s modified comparative negligence rules, where recovery is only possible if you are less than 50% at fault for the accident. This expertise can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case.

Increased Compensation Potential
Experienced personal injury attorneys in New Jersey strive to secure complete compensation for their clients, addressing damages like:
- Healthcare costs
- Lost earnings
- Emotional and physical distress
- Punitive damages, if relevant
These lawyers have a fiduciary responsibility to prioritize their client’s financial welfare. They aim for comprehensive and equitable recompense while carefully handling any settlement funds. Their negotiation tactics are designed to effectively challenge inadequate offers from insurance companies so that clients receive a satisfactory settlement accounting for all of their losses.
The importance of retaining an attorney is underscored by the potential increase in compensation they can bring about in cases involving car accidents. By hiring a lawyer, individuals stand a better chance at receiving greater remuneration following such incidents.
Handling Complex Legal Processes
The legal process following a car accident can be daunting and complex. A lawyer is essential to:
- Understand complex legal language
- Determine the best course of action
- Ensure comprehensive representation for the victim in an injury claim
- Aid in dealing with insurance companies that often employ tactics to minimize payouts
- Protect clients from being pressured into accepting low offers
Attorneys play a crucial role in interpreting New Jersey’s modified comparative negligence laws, where a plaintiff can recover damages only if they are less than 50% at fault; being 50% or more at fault bars recovery.
Experienced attorneys ensure that car accident claims are filed within New Jersey’s legal timeframe, which is two years from the date of the injury, to prevent forfeiture of compensation rights. A car accident attorney manages all aspects of the case, including paperwork and insurance company communications, allowing you, the client, to concentrate on recovery. An attorney’s involvement can lead to a more substantial settlement offer from insurance companies who recognize the heightened likelihood of fair compensation when a knowledgeable lawyer is involved.

How to Choose the Right Car Accident Attorney
When it comes to choosing the right car accident attorney, several factors should be considered. These include:
- The attorney’s experience
- The attorney’s expertise
- The attorney’s communication skills
- The attorney’s transparency
A competent car accident attorney in New Jersey should specialize in personal injury lawsuits and have experience with cases similar to yours. It’s important to examine the attorney’s track record and history of successful outcomes in past similar cases.
After all, your attorney should have the resources to handle insurance cases, including collecting evidence, consulting with medical professionals, and dealing with medical bills.
Experience and Expertise
It’s essential to seek the skilled advice of a personal injury lawyer when navigating through the intricacies involved in a New Jersey-based personal injury claim. Obtaining legal counsel promptly after experiencing a car accident is critical and can have a profound impact on the ultimate resolution of your claim. The worthiness of an attorney is often demonstrated by their familiarity with similar cases and their track record of successful resolutions, showcasing their adeptness at managing claims related to car accidents.
Focusing on mastery within the realm of personal injury law coupled with demonstrable experience winning in court are vital elements that underscore a lawyer’s ability to champion client interests successfully. This focus is why most personal injury lawyers hone these particular aspects, ensuring they are primed to offer substantial representation throughout an individual’s injury claim process.

Communication and Transparency
It’s essential for a competent lawyer to:
- Respond thoroughly to any queries about the strategic direction and methods of their case handling, committing to clear and open communication.
- Transparently work out the contingency fee agreement with consideration for the distinctive aspects of each individual case.
- Be upfront regarding how they will handle overhead expenses.
Lawyers must make themselves accessible to those they serve by providing prompt answers to questions and issues while adhering strictly to their ethical duty towards transparent client-lawyer interaction. They are obliged not only to keep clients regularly informed on developments within their cases, but also adept at demystifying intricate legal jargon into terms that are easily digestible. This diligence is critical in delivering top-tier legal services.
Next Steps
The comprehension of payment arrangements and the crucial involvement of a lawyer in matters concerning car accidents is essential to achieve an equitable compensation. Employing a proficient legal representative increases your likelihood of securing comprehensive reimbursement, maneuvering through intricate judicial procedures, and obtain support both emotionally and mentally. Importantly, attorney’s fees are solely acquired upon successful resolution of your claim, which mitigates any financial jeopardy for you.
When selecting suitable legal counsel, it’s vital to evaluate their track record, proficiency in relevant fields such as personal injury law related to vehicle collisions along with how effectively they communicate and practice transparency. With its commitment to providing no-cost initial consultations paired with a contingency fee approach that emphasizes various motor vehicle incidents including personal injury cases, Mattiacci Injury Law Firm is an esteemed option amongst New Jersey residents seeking justice. The challenges presented by claims following car accidents need not be daunting when professional guidance is accessible ensuring rightful compensation for those affected.
Mattiacci Injury Law: Your Trusted Car Accident Attorneys
By now, you should recognize the importance of having a lawyer in matters pertaining to car accidents and their various fee structures. We would like to introduce Mattiacci Injury Law, a reputable New Jersey law firm that is committed to providing exemplary legal services for those who have suffered injuries in New Jersey. Their practice covers an extensive array of car accident incidents as well as other issues related to personal injury.
What sets Mattiacci Injury Law apart is its compelling offer: they provide confidential case evaluations at no cost and commit that clients will not incur any attorney fees unless successful compensation is secured. The firm’s ability to handle complex cases is strengthened by John Mattiacci, an accomplished trial lawyer licensed in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, recognized for recovering multi-million dollar verdicts and achieving the prestigious ‘AV’ rating from Martindale-Hubbell.
Free Consultation and Contingency Fee Policy
At Mattiacci Injury Law Firm, individuals can arrange for an initial consultation at no cost and with zero obligation. This opportunity provides a chance to review the details of your case and consider potential strategies without facing any financial burden.
Mattiacci Injury Law adheres to a contingency fee arrangement. According to this agreement, attorney fees are only charged if they successfully win your case. Such an approach guarantees that the law firm’s objectives are closely aligned with yours, as their incentive is directly linked to achieving the most favorable result in your legal matter.
Contact Information and Booking Process
If you’re considering moving forward, Mattiacci Injury Law Firm offers a complimentary consultation that can be arranged by:
- Dialing (856) 219-2481 at any hour, as service is available around the clock
- Providing information about your case through an online form accessible on the website of Mattiacci Injury Law
- Engaging instantly via the live chat option for prompt communication
Located at 110 Marter Ave #502a, Moorestown, NJ 08057, directions to reach Mattiacci Injury Law are easily obtainable through Google Maps.

Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a lawyer get from a car accident settlement in New Jersey?
For example, should the amount settled upon be $30,000 from such an incident. The legal representative would obtain $10,000 as payment for services rendered. Consequently, this results in the individual who brought forth the claim retaining $20,000 of said settlement.
Should I hire an attorney after a car accident in New Jersey?
What is the average payout for a car accident in New Jersey?
How much can someone sue for a car accident in New Jersey?
How much does an attorney charge for a car accident in New Jersey?
Categories
- Bicycle Accidents
- Brain Injuries
- Burn Injuries
- Bus Accidents
- Car Accidents
- Construction Accidents
- COVID-19
- Dog Bites
- Drunk Driving
- Injury Insurance
- Medical Malpractice
- Motorcycle Accidents
- Pain and Suffering
- Pedestrian Accidents
- Personal Injury
- Premises Liability
- Product Liability
- Rideshare Accidents
- Settlements & Awards
- Slip and Fall
- Truck Accidents
- Worker's Compensation
- Wrongful Death