Are Personal Injury Settlements Considered Marital Property in PA?

Personal injury settlements are designed to compensate individuals for harm caused by accidents, injuries, or negligence. If you’ve been involved in an accident or suffered a personal injury, you may be entitled to compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages. But what happens when you’re going through a divorce in Pennsylvania? 

The question often arises: Are personal injury settlements considered marital property in PA?

Understanding whether your personal injury settlement is subject to division in a divorce is crucial. In Pennsylvania, the division of property is governed by equitable distribution laws, which means assets are divided fairly (but not necessarily equally) between spouses during divorce. 

However, the classification of a personal injury settlement—whether it’s separate property or marital property—depends on several factors. Let’s break down the key aspects of this issue.

 

What is Marital Property in Pennsylvania?

In Pennsylvania, the court uses the concept of equitable distribution to divide property during a divorce. This means that property acquired during the marriage, with a few exceptions, is considered marital property and will be divided between the spouses. However, property owned by one spouse before the marriage or acquired by gift or inheritance is usually classified as separate property and isn’t subject to division.

The concept of equitable distribution applies to all assets acquired during the marriage, whether tangible (like real estate or personal property) or intangible (such as pensions, investments, and even debts). The court does not automatically divide property equally but rather seeks to divide it in a way that is fair, considering a variety of factors.

While most assets accumulated during the marriage are subject to division, separate property is generally excluded. Separate property includes things like personal belongings brought into the marriage, gifts received during the marriage, and inheritances. But what about personal injury settlements? Are they part of this classification, or do they fall under the broader category of marital property?

 

 

Marital vs. Separate Property

In general, personal injury settlements are not considered marital property in Pennsylvania. This is because the compensation is meant to address an injury suffered by one spouse, and the purpose of the settlement is to make that individual whole again, not to benefit the marital estate. 

However, some nuances must be considered, as the classification can depend on the specifics of the case. Here is a table showing the nuances of this issue:

Here’s a comparison table summarizing key points about personal injury settlements and how they may be classified as marital or separate property in Pennsylvania:

Type of Compensation	Classified as Marital Property?	Reason/Explanation
Pain and Suffering	No	Typically, compensation for pain and suffering is considered separate property because it’s intended to compensate for the individual’s personal injury and emotional distress.
Lost Wages (During Marriage)	Yes	Lost wages are considered marital property if the injury caused the individual to miss work during the marriage. This includes compensation for wages lost during the marriage.
Future Earnings (Lost Earning Capacity)	Yes	If the injury affects the individual’s future earning capacity and the compensation is tied to their employment during the marriage, it may be considered marital property.
Medical Expenses	No	Medical expense compensation is typically separate property, as it is intended for the injured party’s personal recovery and medical costs.
Settlement Used for Marital Expenses (e.g., Mortgage, Joint Purchases)	Yes	If settlement funds are used for joint marital purposes (e.g., paying down a mortgage or joint bills), they may be considered marital property because they benefit both spouses.
Settlement for Injury Occurred During Marriage	Partially Yes	If the injury occurred during the marriage, part of the settlement (e.g., lost wages or future earnings) may be considered marital property, depending on how it is used.
Commingled Funds (Joint Account)	Yes (Potentially)	If settlement funds are mixed with marital funds (e.g., deposited into a joint account or used for shared expenses), the court may classify the commingled portion as marital property.
Personal Injury Funds Not Used for Marital Purposes	No	If settlement funds are kept separate and not used for marital purposes, they are more likely to remain separate property.

Compensation for Pain and Suffering:

The compensation you receive for pain and suffering is generally considered separate property. Pain and suffering payments are meant to compensate for the physical and emotional distress caused by the injury and are awarded to the individual who suffered the harm. Therefore, these funds are typically not divided in a divorce.

This is especially true when the injury was severe and has long-lasting consequences on the injured spouse’s quality of life. For example, if someone receives a substantial settlement for chronic pain and emotional distress following an accident, those funds are usually theirs alone. This is because pain and suffering compensation is seen as personal to the individual, and not something that benefits the marriage.

Lost Wages and Future Earnings:

However, compensation for lost wages or future earnings may be considered marital property. If the injury caused you to miss work during the marriage, any settlement that compensates you for the wages lost during the marriage could be classified as marital property. Similarly, if the settlement is meant to cover the loss of future earning potential (and that potential was developed during the marriage), it may be subject to division in a divorce.

For example, if you were injured in a car accident and had to take time off work, the portion of your settlement that compensates you for the wages you lost during your marriage might be divided as part of the marital estate. In this case, even though the settlement was awarded to one spouse, the marital contributions (in terms of lost income) can be divided.

Medical Expenses:

Settlements that compensate for medical expenses related to the injury are generally considered separate property. These funds are intended to cover the cost of medical treatments, rehabilitation, and other health-related costs incurred due to the injury. Since the medical expenses directly relate to the injured spouse’s recovery, they are usually not subject to division during divorce.

However, in situations where medical expenses were shared by the marital estate (for example, paid out of a joint account), there may be a gray area. Courts may consider how the funds were used when determining whether they should be classified as marital property.

 

When Can a Personal Injury Settlement Be Considered Marital Property?

While the general rule is that personal injury settlements are separate property, there are exceptions where they may be considered marital property. Here are a few situations where this could apply:

1. If the Injury Occurred During the Marriage

If the injury that led to the settlement happened during the marriage, the settlement might include compensation for lost wages or future earnings, which could be considered marital property. For instance, if you were injured in an accident while married and the settlement includes compensation for lost income from your job (even if you haven’t yet received it), that portion of the settlement may be divisible in a divorce.

Pennsylvania courts may view income earned during the marriage as part of the marital estate, and if part of the settlement replaces that income, it may be deemed marital property. For instance, if you were injured in a car crash and lost wages for six months, the portion of your settlement covering those wages would be considered marital property.

2. If Settlement Funds Are Used for Marital Expenses

If the settlement funds are used for joint purposes, such as paying off marital debts, purchasing a home, or improving a marital asset, the court may classify those funds as marital property. If you deposited your personal injury settlement into a joint account or used it for marital purposes, it could be viewed as a contribution to the marital estate and may be divided accordingly.

For example, if you used your personal injury settlement to pay off a joint mortgage or to make significant improvements to the marital home, the court may consider these funds marital property.

3. Commingling of Funds

Commingling refers to the practice of mixing separate property with marital property in a way that makes it difficult to distinguish between the two. If you deposit your settlement check into a joint account or use it to pay for shared expenses, the court may consider the commingled funds to be marital property. Therefore, it’s crucial to maintain clear separation between settlement funds and marital assets to avoid this issue.

If you commingle settlement funds with marital assets or use the funds for joint purchases, it could complicate the situation. Courts will look closely at how the funds were handled and whether the injury-related money was used for marital purposes. This is why it’s important to keep settlement funds in a separate account and avoid using them for family expenses unless you want them to be potentially divided.

 

How Courts Determine the Division of Personal Injury Settlements in Divorce

Under Pennsylvania’s equitable distribution law, the court does not divide marital property equally but rather fairly, based on the circumstances of each case. When it comes to personal injury settlements, the court will examine how the funds were used during the marriage and what portion of the settlement constitutes marital property.

For example, if part of the settlement was used for marital expenses, such as paying for medical bills or home repairs, the court may consider that portion of the settlement as part of the marital estate. On the other hand, compensation for pain and suffering will generally remain the injured spouse’s separate property.

The court will also consider factors when determining how the settlement should be divided such as:

• Length of the marriage
• Each spouse’s financial contributions
• Overall financial situation of both spouses (net worth, debt, etc)

If one spouse used the settlement funds for their own personal benefit (such as paying for individual medical care), the funds may remain separate. However, the court may view the funds differently if the money was used for joint benefits, such as paying down the mortgage.

 

Can You Protect Your Personal Injury Settlement from Being Split in a Divorce?

If you’re concerned about your personal injury settlement being classified as marital property, there are steps you can take to protect it:

1. Keep Settlement Funds Separate

To protect your personal injury settlement, keep the funds in a separate bank account that is solely in your name. Avoid depositing settlement money into a joint account or using it for shared expenses. The clearer the separation between your settlement and marital assets, the easier it will be to maintain it as separate property.

Maintaining separate accounts and avoiding commingling can help prevent your settlement from being considered marital property. The more you can show that the funds were used only for your personal recovery, the better your chances of keeping them separate.

2. Document the Settlement’s Purpose

Keep detailed records of how the settlement was spent, especially if you used any portion of it for personal, non-marital purposes (such as medical treatments). Proper documentation can help clarify which part of the settlement is considered separate property.

If you intend to use your settlement for specific purposes that won’t benefit the marriage, be sure to keep receipts and maintain clear records of how the funds were spent. Documentation is key to protecting your interests.

3. Consider a Prenuptial or Postnuptial Agreement

A prenuptial agreement or postnuptial agreementcan specifically address how personal injury settlements will be handled in the event of a divorce. This can provide clarity and protection if you anticipate receiving such a settlement during the marriage.

By creating an agreement before or during the marriage, you can outline how any personal injury settlements will be treated in the event of a divorce. This agreement can give you peace of mind knowing that your settlement won’t be subject to division unless you decide otherwise.

 

 

What Happens If a Settlement Was Already Spent Before Divorce?

If your personal injury settlement has already been spent before divorce proceedings, the court may look at how the funds were used. For example, if the settlement was used for joint expenses like a home renovation or paying down marital debts, the court could treat the spent funds as part of the marital estate.

If the funds were used for personal expenses and not shared with your spouse, the court may still uphold the separation of the settlement as separate property. However, spending settlement funds on joint assets or expenses could complicate the division process. In some cases, the court might award a greater share of other marital assets to balance out the use of settlement funds.

 

Receive Fair Compensation for Your Traumatic Injuries

Personal injury settlements are generally considered separate property in Pennsylvania, especially when they are compensation for pain and suffering, medical expenses, or other personal losses. 

However, suppose the funds are used for marital purposes or include compensation for lost wages or future earnings during the marriage. In that case, they may be considered marital property subject to division during divorce.

To protect your settlement, keep the funds separate, document their use, and consider legal agreements like pre or postnuptial agreements. In the meantime, if you’re ready to move forward with your personal injury claim, get your free no-obligation consultation or give us a call at (215) 914-6919.

Related Content:

• How Much Do Personal Injury Lawyers Charge in Philadelphia?
• Things to Look for in a Philadelphia Injury Attorney
• How Long Does a Philadelphia Personal Injury Lawsuit Take?
• How Much to Ask For in a Personal Injury Settlement in Philadelphia, PA?